To The Point with Doni Miller
Impact of Recent Elections
Special | 27m 37sVideo has Closed Captions
Dr. Sam Nelson brings a nonpartisan perspective to understanding the forces shaping our democracy.
Today we discuss one of the most consequential topics facing our nation- the impact of the recent elections and what the results mean for the future of public policy, governance, and civic life, especially right here in northwest Ohio. Dr. Sam Nelson, Professor of Political Science at UT brings a thoughtful, nonpartisan perspective to understanding the forces shaping our democracy.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
To The Point with Doni Miller is a local public television program presented by WGTE
To The Point with Doni Miller
Impact of Recent Elections
Special | 27m 37sVideo has Closed Captions
Today we discuss one of the most consequential topics facing our nation- the impact of the recent elections and what the results mean for the future of public policy, governance, and civic life, especially right here in northwest Ohio. Dr. Sam Nelson, Professor of Political Science at UT brings a thoughtful, nonpartisan perspective to understanding the forces shaping our democracy.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch To The Point with Doni Miller
To The Point with Doni Miller is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
The views and opinions expressed into the points are those of the host of the program and its guests.
They do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of public media.
Today we discuss one of the most consequential topics facing our nation, the impact of recent elections and what the results mean for the future of public policy, governance and civic life, especially right here in Northwest Ohio.
Joining us is Doctor Sam Nelson.
Doctor Nelson is a professor of political science at the University of Toledo, a respected scholar whose work examines American politics, constitutional issues, elections, and public leadership.
Doctor Nelson is a frequent commentator on political affairs and brings a thoughtful, nonpartizan perspective to understanding the forces shaping our democracy.
I'm Danny Miller.
Let's get to the point.
Connect with us on our social media pages.
But you know that you also know that you can email me at Donnie underscore Miller at dot org.
And for this episode and any other additional extras, please go to we.org to the point.
It is my pleasure to have with us today.
Doctor Sam Nelson.
Doctor Nelson is an associate professor and chair of political science and public administration at the University of Toledo, and a savant when it comes to politics and the way they impact our community and our world.
And thank you so much for joining us.
I appreciate that.
I really appreciate that.
So I want to know everything you know, think and feel about what just happened to us in this recent election.
And the very first question I'd like to ask is one that you've heard a million times over the past few days, which is what message do you think we were supposed to get from this, the outcome of this last election?
So I think the the, the top message here is a rejection of President Trump in political science.
We think that all midterm elections are a referendum on the president.
There are the voters passing judgment on how did those last two years go.
And we see that every midterm election, this is a consistent pattern.
And when the president is very unpopular, as Donald Trump is right now, which we can see in public polling, then you see these kinds of big wave elections like what we just saw.
Why do you think he's the perception has certainly been that he's been a relatively popular president.
Whether that's been true or not.
That's the perception.
What's caused this downshift.
Well I mean I think it's interesting.
There's kind of a media narrative about him that looked at the 2024 presidential election, which was a very narrow win.
He only one by 1.6 points.
That was like 47th biggest election win in history, right?
So it's a very narrow win.
But the narrative that came out of that is somehow the ground had shifted.
It was a new country.
Everything was different.
Democrats had to get on board or adjust to the reality of Trump world.
And that was a false narrative.
I think that was a much too narrow of a win.
And he was never what you would call popular.
At the point that he was sworn in in January of 25.
He was at about 50, 51% public approval, which is not bad.
But normally a new president is running pretty high.
People are usually pretty happy after they've won, and it's been a steady decline since then.
So I don't know.
I think there's a disjunction between maybe a media narrative about the president and where the voters actually are, because they clearly have been responding in approval polling for the last two years that they like him less and less over time.
I yeah, I see that point of view.
The, the the reality is, however, that the world has shifted under, under this president and shifted in ways that some folks think are good.
Obviously the folks who follow him who are part of MAGA and folks who don't, who struggle with it sometimes and awful lot like the the elimination of of the the woke, the woke ideology, the d I D-I approach to equality and equity in our system.
Well, I think we're going to see some, some pushback against that now that you have large Democratic majority in Congress.
I think the other place where a lot of the action was in terms of the reaction to die and so on, was in what we call civil society.
It was at law firms and universities, people who don't actually work for the president, who are not elected, who are not, shouldn't be responsive to executive orders.
Executive orders are memos from the boss to executive agencies to do certain things.
They're not instructions to people who don't work for the government.
And so I think what we're going to see in the wake of this very large election result for Democrats is that some of those law firms are going to rethink how compliant do we want to be with the kind of job owning we're getting from the white House?
Universities may think, well, how compliant do we want to be?
Are we going to jump every time he says jump?
Or now do we see, oh, the people aren't necessarily behind what he's been doing.
I mean, there may be an equilibrium that you reach in the future, but I suspect that some of the kind of core commitments of some of these civil society institutions will kind of bounce back a little bit.
I don't think it's going to be a priority, say, in state legislatures, the Democrats recently took over or in Congress to necessarily focus on Dei issues.
Sure, at the beginning.
But I think the pressure from the white House kind of dissipates when he doesn't have Congress, when he has, you know, lost a bunch of state governments, governorships and state legislatures.
Yeah.
You know, as I mentioned to you before, before the show today, I was watching some things, some political analysis just before the election, and Marjorie Taylor Greene was on the panel.
And the question was, is this the end of MAGA?
And she quickly, without hesitation, said, absolutely, MAGA is dead.
What's your response to that?
Maggie's had quite a presence during this campaign and this election.
According to Marjorie Taylor, Greene has eliminated the power of of that caucus.
What do you think?
So, Marjorie Taylor Greene is really kind of an interesting figure.
She was a huge Trump backer for a long time.
She was a Maga star, and now she's kind of an apostate.
She's left.
And, you know, she's one of its biggest critics.
A lot of her criticism turned on The Epstein files, and what she saw as a cover up of the Epstein files and the administration.
But MAGA is not the whole Republican Party.
MAGA by itself is not enough to win a presidential election or to win a governorship in Ohio, and so on.
There are the kind of the the some people self-identify as a Maga Republican.
They voted for Republicans in this election, about 97, 98% non MAGA Republicans, kind of maybe a more traditional kind of chamber of commerce or country club Republican.
About 20% of them in many states broke with the Republicans and voted for Democratic candidates.
That's a sign that MAGA doesn't have a coalition large enough by itself to continue to win elections.
They're going to need to restore their connection with more conventional Republicans, and with Republican leaning and conservative independence, in order to get to a majority again.
So do you think that this past election says to President Trump, you got it wrong.
You've had it wrong the whole time.
Well, whether he could hear that message or not.
I think it's a different yeah, that's a different question.
I mean, I think that presidents of either party who have faced these kinds of midterm defeats and Democrats have and Republicans have in the past, they usually kind of get up the next day and say, well, what are we going to do to reconnect with the voters?
So far, we haven't seen that from President Trump.
And, you know, I think it's doubtful that we'll see that he immediately named Stephen Miller as his chief of staff.
That's the thing about that.
Well, it's the opposite of the direction that, say, George W Bush would have gone in this situation or Barack Obama would have gone in this situation.
Normally you would look for a a moderating force or somebody who could maybe reach out to voters that you had lost, but he's doubled down.
Stephen Miller is really the architect of the most unpopular Trump policies.
And so, you know, we talk about Trump's popularity.
It's probably going to continue to go down.
If he's truly doubling down, is he going to get on board and maybe compromise with Democrats on some things that improve affordability for regular people?
We haven't seen any sign of that.
He's threatening to veto everything that comes out.
And so he's not a conciliatory president or a conciliatory person.
And so I expect, you know, a lot of tough fights between Democrats in Congress and the president going forward.
Would you say, though, to Democrats, this has not been this election, the results of this election?
Don't pretend some total embracing of of historically democratic approaches to policy.
Would you say to them that they need to do some things different?
Well, I think they need to look for the things that, you know, popular policy.
They know that affordability was a key concern, right.
So they might focus on restoring Medicaid cuts, restoring Affordable Care Act subsidies, going after the tariffs that have raised prices in a lot of areas trying to end the Iran war.
Those are all affordability issues.
Those are broadly kind of popular moves that they could probably make, but they can't take for granted that 2028 is going to go the way 2026 did.
Sometimes that happens.
2006 was a big Democratic wave.
So was 2008.
But 2008 was a very good election for Democrats in 2010.
They got wiped out.
Yeah.
In the Obama midterms.
And so they're going to be cautious about that.
Also, a bunch of people got elected in places that Democrats don't win elections.
House districts that have ten point Republican advantages.
States like Kansas and Mississippi where Democrats don't win Senate elections.
A lot of those candidates are going to be cautious.
They're going to be fairly moderate in terms of what they push in policy.
Whoever the Senate majority leader ends up being is not going to be pushing, you know, the Green New Deal or something like that.
They're going to be looking for things that have kind of broad support across the caucus between the progressives and the centrists.
Some of the more conservative members hoping to avoid some of the hot button issues.
You're not going to see a bill protecting trans rights coming out of the House in the next six months.
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
That would be difficult for the caucus, I think.
But I think some of these affordability issues that unites the caucus across the ideological spectrum.
You know what I wonder, though, Doctor Nelson, is the the issues that were raised by, by the MAGA Republicans were important to them.
They were very vocal about those issues.
Some of those issues were extremely legitimate.
And if you speak to MAGA Republicans, all of those issues were legitimate issues.
Where is the where is that voice now?
Where are those concerns now?
They simply they don't go away simply because the president is unpopular or Democrats have the the bully pulpit right now.
I mean, a lot of those issues change from election to election.
I mean, just as we were just talking about how Democrats risk overeating, the success they just had, I think MAGA over read Trumps win in 2024 and thought, oh, we won because we ran a bunch of anti-trans ads or because we were, you know, really going to be very tough on immigration.
But those policies haven't turned out to be as popular as they assumed they were going to be.
And you get this kind of rejection that we've just seen.
I think they believed that they had more of the public on their side.
Some of this is coming from judging public opinion by being on X or, you know, Twitter and other social media, instead of maybe looking at public opinion polling, maybe instead of talking to voters.
We spent a great deal of time, I think, or the media spent a great deal of time after 2024 interviewing Trump voters.
What do you really want?
Why do you feel isolated?
You know, the joke is kind of, you know, they went to Ohio diners in rural counties.
Right.
Well, you know, they're going to go to diners in urban areas now and ask the people who just rejected the Republicans what they want out of things.
So, yeah, the MAGA issues are going to be there.
But one other question is Trump going to ask you to hold that question?
We're going to go to break right now.
But don't forget it.
Don't forget it okay.
We're going to go away for just a minute, but we'll be right back.
To me, community means connecting to others.
I'm Danny Miller and welcome to the point.
Yay!
We're a community committed to education.
Discover new ideas, dive into exciting subject, and engage with the world around you.
I would send them personally a t shirt.
Crime doesn't pay in the old West End.
Pass it on.
That's how we cleaned up the neighborhood.
Vision loss for people is not the end.
It's a story.
It's the next chapter.
WD Public Media invites you to get out and play.
Dave.
Weekdays 5PMWE HD 3 p.m.
on FM 91.
And of course always.org.
WTE.
Where you come to watch, listen and learn.
Connect with us on our social media pages.
You should also email me at Donnie Underscore Miller at dot org.
And as always, if you'd like to see this episode again or any others that particularly struck your fancy, go to we.org.
To the point we are talking to Doctor Sam Nelson.
As you heard in the first segment.
Doctor Nelson is an associate professor and chair of Political science and Public administration at the University of Toledo.
And a person who lives, breathes, and loves the art of politics.
We're so happy to have you with us.
We went to break and you were saying so we were talking about MAGA issues and where they go from here.
And I think one of the things that we don't know.
It's the presidential election.
The primaries on the Republican side are really going to give us an indication here is whether there is another Republican leader who can activate the MAGA base.
The way that Donald Trump did, his political skill was activating voters who don't always participate in politics.
They didn't show up during this election.
They show up for him, but not others.
Can Ron DeSantis or JD Vance or Marco Rubio activate that base and speak in a way that they see as authentic about the issues that maybe they care about without alienating independence?
More conventional Republicans, without activating Democratic opposition, and big Democratic turnout?
You know, it's a very narrow line to to walk in whether Trump did it through skill and on purpose or whether it be lucked into it, you know, is a historical judgment for later.
Yeah.
But he clearly could do it.
But nobody else has shown the ability to do it.
That's absolutely true.
One of one of the things that is so apparent in discussions about voter trends in this last election is that he lost a lot of folks that perhaps some of us were surprised that he gathered in the first place Latino men, black men.
What what do you think most influenced those groups this time that caused them to say, well, we're we're not happy.
Well, I think there were a couple of different things.
I think Broken Promises is one of the things.
I think he appealed to Latino voters on an immigration message where they thought that they would benefit and not be harmed by his approach to immigration.
I think men in general saw his offer of increased manufacturing, employment, maybe traditional, traditionally masculine jobs, but 75% of the jobs created in the last two years went to women, not to men.
So they didn't see the payoff that they may have envisioned.
He also promised no new wars or no stupid wars.
And then we have the Iran war.
And I think that that is a feeling of betrayal from some of those groups.
I think that Republicans built their gerrymandered maps in Texas around the idea that they had won Latinos forever.
And that's clearly not what happened in Texas.
Yeah, backfired in a big way.
And they lost some of those districts, assuming that that voting behavior had had changed permanently.
And so, you know, I think we we saw the swing back here.
And I think a lot of those voters are still kind of up for grabs.
And I don't think Democrats can take for granted that they'll get those votes in 28.
But yeah, that's a really interesting perspective, because in so many ways, this election has been has been described as an anybody but Donald Trump, not necessarily a total embracing of democratic ideology or or purpose.
What advice if if Hakeem called you or, or someone of that ilk called you and said, what should we do?
What would you tell them?
I think, you know, try to pass popular policy and do accountability where it makes sense, where you're laying the groundwork for future legislative wins and things like that.
I mean, Mayor Mamdani in New York is a good example.
Somebody who came in and people had some people in New York had some doubts about him, and he's just done popular thing after popular thing, and his approval rating has gone up.
Absolutely.
He fixes potholes.
He fixes the day to day, you know, inconveniences of life as a New Yorker.
And we have different problems as a country, obviously, but we have things that people want fixed.
My health care premiums are too high.
You know, my property taxes are too high, whatever it might be, and addressing those things or at least being seen.
I mean, they'll pass legislation, no question.
They've got big majorities.
Trump has the veto pen.
Right.
So whether they can enact the legislation, but to be seen fighting for those things really can rally people around and can say, oh, you're the do something party, right?
You're offering me an alternative.
But it's you know, it's very difficult.
And voting against is a very common thing.
Negative Partizanship what, what we're against, what we dislike as a strong motivator.
Yeah.
Any impact of this election on northwest Ohio?
I think maybe the state elections.
Certainly having a Democratic governor for the first time in 16 years, having most of the statewide offices held by Democrats, we're going to see some different messaging and some different priorities in Columbus, which should affect us.
We didn't see a change right in Ohio.
Nine Marcy Kaptur is still there.
So, you know, northwest Ohio still kind of being represented.
Marcy Kaptur and Bob later, the same people who were there.
But the priorities of some of them are are much higher in a Congress dominated by Democrats than we saw.
And so I think I think we will see some changes in that way.
And certainly coming out of Columbus.
Yeah.
So I'm just curious about your perspective on the ad that was run by the Ramaswamy do, because he seemed competitive until that ad.
I was really I really wasn't clear.
They were neck and neck for a great a great portion of that contest.
And then that ad came along.
What do you think?
Well, it was, I think pretty clearly a big mistake.
And I think trying to figure out why that mistake was made.
I mean, part of it is he had never really run for office before.
I mean, he briefly ran for president two years ago.
He was an inexperienced candidate.
And running a campaign is a skill position, right?
And so maybe judgment.
There was poor judgment in placing the ad.
I think they thought it was going to be this big winner for them.
And it's utterly mystifying.
I mean, you know, the immediate reaction to it and many, many Republicans rejected it as well.
It wasn't sort of, oh, Democrats don't like this, right?
I mean, it was clearly governor DeWine and other leading state Republicans thought, what are you doing?
What are you thinking here?
And I think that that probably I don't think it turned the race, but I think you're right that it probably.
I mean, if we look, Acton won by about eight points.
Shared Brown won his race by about five.
So that spread of three points.
The ad is part of that three.
It's not the whole thing.
I would agree, but it's part of that.
I think that's true as well.
You know, one of the things that I heard absolutely everywhere I went during this election season is we are tired of these ads.
There are too many of them and they don't they're not informative in any real way.
What they are is nasty.
Right.
Do you think that that our elected officials are out of touch with what the real people are saying, that people with boots on the ground are actually saying?
So I think this is a real problem.
And this really, in some ways dates to Citizens United, a Supreme Court case for about 12, 13 years ago that opened the spigot to outside spending.
So if you look at who placed the negative ads that we react the most against, it's outside spending.
It's PACs that maybe are headquartered in Florida or Washington, D.C.
it's not generally the candidates themselves who are behind that.
That was one of the strange things about the Ramaswami ad against Amy Acton that we were just talking about, because it was paid for by the campaign.
But if you look at the Senate race, half $1 billion was spent in our Senate race, but most of that money was not from John Husted and Sherrod Brown.
It was the PACs supporting them.
The PACs really have, I think, incentives that line up for running the negative ads, negative ads, unfortunately, do kind of work.
Do they?
Their effective they're effective at pushing down the favorable of your opponent and making you less motivated to vote.
They can depress turnout or depress turnout and vote for your opponent.
And so as long as they work, the PACs are going to run them.
Unfortunately, we were really unindicted here in Ohio because of that Senate race.
You know, in Illinois, you wouldn't have heard nearly so many negative ads because they didn't have competitive races.
Do you think that those ads contributed to what felt like at least a large, a large degree of polarization?
I think there I think there may be reflective of polarization.
You're usually looking for whether you're a Democrat or a Republican, you're looking for wedge issues that kind of split your opponent's base of support.
And so, you know, for Republicans in recent elections, that's been things like trans issues for Sherrod Brown.
This time it was data centers.
That was a great wedge issue for him to get Republican voters to be open to what he was doing.
He had a lot of attack ads against his involvement with data centers.
I think I think a lot of people would like to see more positive advertising.
They'd like to see more positive messaging from candidates.
I don't think we have a media environment that really supports those kinds of campaigns.
And social media probably isn't helping either, because what goes viral?
It's the gotcha moment.
The rage baked.
The things that make people angry is what gets heavy engagement in social media algorithms.
So we're kind of up against a lot of problems.
People aren't getting what they want out of a campaign, kind of as consumers of campaign information.
But the incentives aren't there for the providers of campaign information to provide what we want.
What would it take to get big money out of politics?
There's a lot of that discussion.
You know, we're going to get big money out of politics.
And when I think about it, I think that's a huge, huge task.
It really is.
And the Supreme Court and courts are my special area of focus.
The Supreme Court has made it extremely difficult to do campaign finance reform or to put limits on political advertising.
They've read First Amendment law in a way that really has opened the gates to unlimited amounts of spending.
And then when you look at where the money is coming from.
You know, Elon Musk dropped close to a half $1 billion on this race.
That's amazing.
But that's couch cushion money for me, right?
You know, I mean, that's right.
Wait, I said that wrong for him.
You know, it's it would be trivial.
For him, he can afford to do that every two years if he wants.
And that drowns out kind of the absolutely standard small donors who do ten and $20, who kind of stretch to send $20 to a candidate.
And so, I don't know, there's not a simple solution.
I think Democrats will certainly talk about it because they feel that they're they were outspent by a large margin nationally in this election.
So they care about it for Partizan reasons.
Republicans care about it because they are advantage right now.
So it's it's a tough nut to crack.
It is a tough nut to crack.
There is so much to talk about here.
I have a list of like 30 other questions and we are out of time.
So you will have to come back.
Okay.
Promise.
All right.
All right.
Thank you so much.
And thank you all for joining us today.
I appreciate it.
Make sure that you continue to remain involved and engaged and make sure that your voice is heard in this democracy.
You go out and have a great day.
I'll see you next time.
On to the point.
The views and opinions expressed into the points are those of the host of the program and its guests.
They do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of public media.
To the point is supported in part by viewers like you.
Thank you.
Impact of Recent Elections promo
Airs Friday, November 13th at 8:30 p.m. and repeats Sunday, November 15th at 11:00 a.m. (30s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
To The Point with Doni Miller is a local public television program presented by WGTE

